This usually happens with my group, too. Hard to say. Contacting the pending member outside the system usually yields no conclusion. Often, I email Mark at support to complain about an NC, yet very

And lo and behold not long after the above the member concerned did respond and the NC flag has vanished. So was the earlier Confirmation Email delivered and ignored or was it not delivered? The

Hello, Would it be possible to add a third option to the Calendar Events Repeat section to select the Last day of the month? For example: Repeats: Monthly Repeat Every: 1 months Repeat by day of the

And further, don't send any group-member-specific emails - including the Welcome message - to any unconfirmed or unverified members, even if approved. If you want to send member-specific content to

Also the displays and badges, as I mentioned. -- J Messages are the sole opinion of the author, especially the fishy ones. My humanity is bound up in yours, for we can only be human together. -

Missed that but I 100% agree with you. -- J Messages are the sole opinion of the author, especially the fishy ones. My humanity is bound up in yours, for we can only be human together. - Desmond

Yes, that's why I earlier used Confirm for the account and Verify for the group. Might be worth changing the wording in the email sent when attempting to join a group to clarify the two. Duane

Maybe the situation could be revised along the following lines. Have an account status "unconfirmed account," which attaches to an email address and would display as UA. Have a separate status, which

Typo with double negatives. Should read "yet does not display when a member not confirmed their interest in a second group even after having been asked to confirm" -- J Messages are the sole

While doing some research on another #bug (https://beta.groups.io/g/main/topic/73955560), I ran into an anomaly. It appears that if you've ever been a member of a group, your application to join

Yes, yes, yes. I have reported this as a bug several times, and just did so again yesterday in a message to support. And that's just one problem among the many cited here. The confirmation process is

Nevertheless, if this is the first group someone is joining, and that group happens to be a premium restricted group, the group can confirm the member (INCLUDING removing the NC) by approving their

NC is strictly a function of the account. It's only needed once per account, regardless of the number of groups joined. After confirming your email address this way, you do still need to verify that

IMHO there is another anomalous factor in play. The group I co - own has on occasions admitted members who have not responded to the Confirmation Message, but who have responded to the Pending

Yes, I'm aware of that. I wanted to make sure that the situation hadn't changed again since then. Andy

I agree with Duane. My point was that in essence, Shal is arguing that restricted groups should be allowed to confirm their members upon approval, but without removing the N.C. That’s like trying to

I don't see that it makes any difference. The NC is related to their account, not their membership. If they become a member, automatically (unrestricted) or approved (restricted), it should be sent

And by the way, this ^^^ just bolsters my previous argument that restricted groups should automatically confirm members when they approve them, rather than having it be a premium

There exist restricted groups with no real restrictions - that is, the group is technically restricted and needs to approve memberships, but actually accepts any email address that applies. In those

J, Can you clarify a point for me, are these members or pending members? That is, if you have a restricted group and you haven't approved their membership yet then I agree, NC status should not