Well I’m not sure about that, maybe it would need to be a pretty low entry price, based on the number of features to be included. None of the group members have much money, but it would mean

Same advantage as the icon provides generally. The same message at the top of the screen appears for a regular moderated topic. Email users don't see that icon, either. So you may as well argue that

For an online user, there's a message at the top of the screen that states when a message needs to be approved by Moderators. Having an additional icon would seem to just give them advanced warning

John, >>> it's a big jump from free to premium I (and others) also agree and there have been several times in the past when this was discussed, here and on GMF. >>> We'd

Exactly. And if they don't, they will wonder why their message didn't go through. Which is why the icon should be there for their information. I'm done. -- J Messages are the sole opinion of the

I thought I'd be stating the obvious if I included 'if they have relevant permissions' Andy

In fact, at that time it was possible that mods couldn't yet reply to locked topics. I don't remember exactly when Mark made the change. But in any event. it should be displayed now since it's not a

At that time, I was unaware that mod replies to locked+moderated topics would be moderated. In fact, it's even possible, depending on the change history, that mods were unable to reply to locked

Thanks for finding that conversation. As I explained, I was unaware then that mod replies would be moderated. Not all moderators have message approval permissions, or even viewability of pending

>>> Currently, a topic that's both locked and moderated displays only the locked icon. But unless and until the change allowing mods to reply to locked topics is undone, I think topics that are both

You seemed to be arguing the other way in September #30319. If a topic is locked and moderated then for the majority of members, the locked icon will be most significant. If a moderator posts a

I am the owner of several small community focussed (not commercial) groups. At the moment they are all free. One of these groups has 50 members and would really benefit from access to the calendar

Currently, a topic that's both locked and moderated displays only the locked icon. But unless and until the change allowing mods to reply to locked topics is undone, I think topics that are both

But in that case you wouldn't refer to "save and send." -- J Messages are the sole opinion of the author, especially the fishy ones. My humanity is bound up in yours, for we can only be human

It can also imply editing during moderation... sometimes required unfortunately. Chris

Haven't seen the GMF post (I'm not in there), but what's the difference? If you're editing and saving, that kinda implies the message already exists, i.e., is "old." -- J Messages are the sole

Is this the same problem that you raised on the GMF or a subtly different one? I ask because here you talk of edit old messages while your GMF query related to When we edit and save messages, with no

Works fine for me. -- J Messages are the sole opinion of the author, especially the fishy ones. My humanity is bound up in yours, for we can only be human together. - Desmond Tutu

When you say not being sent to the group, does your edited message appear in the Archive? Did you check your Activity Log as suggested by Chris when you raised this on GMF? Also, have you checked your

When I edit old messages and save the edit, it works fine. However, when I edit and click the "save and send to group" option, the messages are not being sent to the group. Please could someone check